Do you want to learn to make your own goat milk yogurt? This guide will help you make your own yogurt using goat milk plus 3 different ways to incubate and tips on making thicker yogurt.

One of the perks of having your own dairy goats is that you get fresh, raw milk whenever you want. But it doesn’t stop there- you can use your milk to make cheeses (like goat milk mozzarella!), kefir, caramel sauce, buttermilk, and fresh homemade goat milk yogurt!

This site contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase using one of these links, I may earn a commission. Please see my disclosure page for more information about cookies collected and our privacy policy.

Like a lot of products made with goat milk, it can be kind of tricky to get your homemade yogurt to turn out just right.

But with a few tips you can have the best goat milk yogurt- fresh from your goat to the table!


How to Make Goat Milk Yogurt: Plus 3 Ways to Incubate!


How to Make Goat Milk Yogurt

The first step to any cheese and yogurt making is sterilization of your utensils and work space. This is very important so that you don’t add in any bad bacteria to your milk before you incubate it.

When making yogurt on the stove I simply place a bit of water in my pot and stick all my utensils inside then boil it for a few minutes- or until the water has fully evaporated.


What you will need:

1/2 gallon of goat milk

2-3 T of organic yogurt or Yogurt starter cultures


Glass jars for incubation- pint or quart

cooler/dehydrator/yogurt maker


For the purpose of this recipe, I will be using store bought yogurt for my cultures. If you use starter cultures, much of the process will be the same, but follow the directions on the packet for the addition of the cultures.


How to Make the Yogurt:

Place your milk in a large pot over medium-low heat.

Bring it to a temperature of 180F while stirring frequently.

(*You can skip this part if you want raw milk yogurt, but the resulting yogurt will be much thinner due to the fact that the cultures will have to compete with the natural occurring bacteria in the raw milk*)


thermometer clipped to the side of a pot of fresh goat milk



Once the milk has reached 180 F, remove it from the heat and place it in an ice bath, stirring occasionally, until it comes to 110 F.

While the milk is cooling, set out your yogurt starter so that it warms up a bit.

I use organic, plain whole milk yogurt.


pot of goat milk cooling in an ice bath


When the milk reaches the correct temperature, gently stir in the yogurt starter and mix well.

Pour into 2 quart jars or 4 pints.

Allow it to incubate at a steady warm temperature (~110F) for 6-12 hours.

I like mine at about a 6-8 hour incubation- the longer you let it sit, the more tart or sour tasting it will be.


Do you like this recipe? Get it and 24 other fabulous goat milk recipes in my Goat Milk Recipe E-Book! With recipes for cheeses, yogurt, kefir and treats like ice cream and fudge!


How to Incubate Your Goat Milk Yogurt:

You have a couple of options when it comes to incubating your yogurt:

  1. Use a yogurt maker. Such as the Euro Cuisine Yogurt maker. Just follow the instructions for your machine.
  2. Place it in your dehydrator. My Excalibur works great for this. Just remove the trays and set your jars inside.
  3. Use a cooler. Fill a couple of jars with boiling or really hot water and set them, and your yogurt jars, inside of the cooler and close it up. Walk away for at least 6 hours before opening up the cooler. I used this method for years. It works well and it takes no extra electricity.


goat milk yogurt incubating in a cooler with a jar of boiling water


Regardless of which method you use, the key is a steady temperature and an undisturbed incubation period.

Once your incubation is complete, set your jars of homemade yogurt in the fridge to cool and thicken up a bit.

And you are done! My kids like to stir in a bit of maple syrup or honey and just drink it like kefir from a glass. It’s great with granola or mixed with fruit too! Let me know if you give it a try!


goat milk yogurt in a small jar with a spoon full


Is Thick Goat Milk Yogurt Possible?

Like with many dairy products, goat milk yogurt can be tricky to get to a thick consistency. All goat milk is different so playing around with different cultures, incubation period lengths and incubation methods will help you find the method that gives you the best results.

The normal suggestions are to stir in dry milk powder or gelatin into the goat milk as you heat it. I am not willing to make these additions just for the sake of thickening it up, so I usually settle for somewhat runny goat milk yogurt that is more drinkable than spoonable.

It still tastes great and much is less expensive than the organic store bought varieties and with much less additives!